Metal vs. Shingle Roofing: Weighing the Options for Midwest Homes

When it comes to choosing a roof for your midwest home, the decision often boils down to two popular options: metal roofing and asphalt shingles. Each material offers unique advantages and challenges, particularly when considering our region's distinctive climate and environmental factors. Let's dive into the benefits and drawbacks of both options to help you make an informed choice.

Metal Roofing

Benefits:

1. Exceptional Durability

• Metal roofing stands up to the midwest's harsh winters, heavy snow, and intense summer heat. 
• It's resistant to cracking, shrinking, and warping, making it a long-lasting option (up to 50 years or more when professionally installed). 

2. Superior Weather Resistance 

• Metal roofs shed snow and ice easily, preventing the formation of ice dams—a common issue in colder climates. 
• They also withstand high winds and severe storms, which are frequent in the midwest. 

3. Energy Efficiency 

• Reflective coatings on metal roofs reduce heat absorption during the hot summer months, lowering cooling costs. 
• In the winter, proper insulation under a metal roof retains warmth effectively. 

4. Low Maintenance 

• Metal roofs are resistant to mold, mildew, and pests. 
• Their longevity means fewer repairs and replacements over time. 

5. Expanded Design Options 

• Modern metal roofing now mimics the look of stone, slate, wood shakes, and even traditional shingles, offering homeowners versatile aesthetic choices. 
• These designs allow you to achieve the charm of classic materials without compromising the durability and benefits of metal. 

6. Increased Home Value 

• Metal roofing is seen as a premium feature by buyers, adding significant resale value to your home. 
• Its longevity, energy efficiency, and modern aesthetic appeal make it a strong selling point for prospective buyers. 

7. Eco-Friendly 

• Most metal roofing materials are recyclable and can contribute to sustainability efforts in the midwest.

Drawbacks:

1. Higher Upfront Cost 

• Metal roofing typically costs more than shingles, which may not fit all budgets. However, the long lifespan can offset the initial investment. 

2. Potential for Noise 

• Without proper insulation, rain or hail can be louder on a metal roof, though modern installation techniques mitigate this issue. 

3. Expansion and Contraction 

• Metal expands and contracts with temperature changes, potentially stressing fasteners or panels over time. 

Asphalt Shingles

Benefits:

1. Affordability 

• Shingles are significantly less expensive than metal roofing, making them a budget-friendly option for homeowners. 
• Repairs are also more affordable due to the availability of materials and contractors. 

2. Aesthetic Options 

• Asphalt shingles come in various colors and textures.
• They can mimic materials like wood or slate at a fraction of the cost. 

3. Ease of Installation 

• Shingles are quicker and simpler to install than metal roofing, reducing labor costs and project timelines. 

4. Good Performance in Temperate Conditions 

• Shingles can handle moderate weather well, offering reliable protection in areas with milder winters and summers. 

5. Moderate Home Value Impact 

• While not as long-lasting as metal roofing, a new shingle roof still adds value to your home by improving curb appeal and ensuring structural integrity. 

Drawbacks:

1. Shorter Lifespan 

• Midwest weather, with its freeze-thaw cycles and heavy precipitation, can cause shingles to deteriorate quicker. 
• Expect to replace them every 15-30 years, depending on the material quality and maintenance. 

2. Vulnerability to Extreme Weather 

• High winds, hailstorms, and ice dams can damage shingles, leading to frequent repairs. 
• Shingles are more prone to leaks if not installed correctly or if they age poorly. 

3. Higher Maintenance 

• Algae and moss growth are common issues in the humid midwest summers, particularly in shaded areas. 
• Routine inspections and cleaning are necessary to prolong their lifespan. 

4. Energy Efficiency Challenges 

• Shingles absorb heat, which can raise cooling costs in the summer unless you choose light-colored or reflective options. 

Adding Value to Your Home with the Right Roof

Whether you choose metal or shingles, replacing your roof can significantly increase your home's resale value. A well-installed roof boosts curb appeal, assures potential buyers of the home’s structural integrity, and reduces future maintenance costs for the next owner. Metal roofs often have the edge in terms of value addition due to their durability, energy efficiency, and premium appearance. However, a new asphalt shingle roof also provides a strong return on investment, especially when installed by a trusted contractor.

What’s Best for Midwest Homes?

When deciding between metal and shingle roofing, consider these key midwest-specific factors:

Climate: Metal roofing performs exceptionally well in extreme conditions like heavy snow and storms, while shingles are better suited to temperate weather patterns.

 

Budget: Shingles offer a cost-effective solution upfront, while metal roofing provides long-term value with its durability. 

Design Preferences: Modern metal roofing offers as much, if not more, design flexibility than asphalt shingles, with styles that mimic traditional materials like slate or wood. 

Longevity: If you're planning to stay in your home for decades, metal roofing may be the more economical choice over time. 

Need Help Choosing the Right Roof?

At Full Service Roofing, we understand the unique demands of Midwest weather and how it impacts your roofing needs. Whether you're leaning toward metal roofing for its durability and modern design options or asphalt shingles for their affordability and familiarity, our team is here to guide you through the decision-making process. Contact us today for a consultation and personalized recommendation tailored to your home and budget!